The main difference between a pro and a home gamer is the amount of tasting that occurs during the preparation, from start to finish. One of the golden rules is every time something goes into the pan, season and taste. The amount of seasoning in your food will be determined not by teaspoons, grams, or any measuring tool, rather by the feeling in your fingertips and your developing palate. One way you can think about the seasoning process is by answering a simple question; how close to fully seasoned is this at this moment?
It is a good idea to make a distinction here between seasoning and flavoring/other. When we talk about seasoning, we are always talking about salt, and pepper if you’re into it. Everything else that could go into the pan is not seasoning although it may be a salty product like parmesan, soy sauce, or bacon.
Q: How much salt should be in pasta water?
A: Enough so you can taste it. “DO NOT MAKE THE PASTA WATER SALTY LIKE THE SEA!” Your sauce will be seasoned and balanced with acid, and if your pasta is too salty you cannot save it.
Q2: How much salt should be in pommes puree and how do I ensure full seasoning, but not kill it with too much?
A: Enough so you can taste it. You are starting with cold water so you can taste it immediately when it hits the burner and taste it again every 5m until the potatoes are done. You will be adding seasoned cream, butter, and potentially more salt later so do not overdo it in the beginning.
Q: I’ve put too much salt in the dish, can it be saved?
A: Well, maybe. If it is a soup or stock, you can discard half of the liquid and replace it with water. Bring it up to the simmer and taste it. If it is a vegetable dish, you can add some water or stock and discard the juices when you give it a stir. Repeat as necessary and be careful. If it is a gratin, casserole, or other layered dish, then no.
Seasoning Guidelines:
- If you are tasting it from the beginning, you shouldn’t be caught off guard by the amount of salt in the dish.
- You can mess it up at the beginning, the middle, and the end. Small amounts of seasoning at every stage.
- If you do over season it, do not continue! Take a step back and evaluate where the dish is in the prep and make an executive decision.
- If you go into salvage mode, you are still on the hook for tasting the food for the rest of the way. This learning experience will teach you way more than you think!
- If you wouldn’t eat it, don’t serve it. Chalk it up to experience and try not to be so heavy-handed next time.
I am beating a dead horse about this seasoning thing, but I assure you your food is likely under seasoned. The next time you are cooking, make a mental note about how many times you added salt and how many times you tasted it. It should be more than ten.